For the longest time, enterprises have been building point-to-point application integrations with ERP systems, using custom code, to improve business efficiency and automation. However, the e-commerce boom brought in a huge wave of SaaS solutions and cloud apps that businesses suddenly needed to integrate their legacy systems with. Integrations became facilitators of digital transformation and business automation. While point-to-point integrations always worked as a means to build long-term integrations between monolithic software systems, they didn’t fulfill the new market demand for businesses to interchangeably integrate multiple applications. As a result, the Alumio iPaaS (integration Platform as a Service) emerged as a cloud-native, low-code integration solution created by experienced developers and integration experts looking to enable this. It’s a next-gen solution that leverages the power of APIs to build fast, flexible, and future-proof integrations. This blog explores the key differences between building point-to-point integrations with custom code and low-code integrations with the Alumio iPaaS, in the face of the rapidly evolving demand of application integrations across industries.
Point-to-point integrations vs the Alumio iPaaS
Modern organizations are increasingly relying on the integration of various systems, applications, and data sources to enable real-time data exchange, automate business processes, improve customer experiences, and most importantly, to accelerate digital transformation. However, this raises the key question of what is the most effective and future-proof method of building integrations. As mentioned in the introduction, while the traditional method involves building point-to-point integration with custom code, the Alumio iPaaS (integration Platform as a Service) presents itself as a next-gen, API-driven alternative to build and manage multiple integrations. Let’s explore the differences between these two integration methods!
What are point-to-point integrations?
Point-to-point integrations involve connecting two applications with custom code, in order to enable them to exchange data and services. These integrations require businesses to employ senior developers or third-party integration experts to develop, manage, and troubleshoot, and they can only be understood by coding experts. Therefore, point-to-point integrations can be an effective solution for businesses looking to integrate any two systems and offer the advantage of tailoring each connection to meet specific needs.
The key difference in point-to-point integrations
Building point-to-point integrations can involve long and expensive custom-coding projects. Adding complex customizations and the need to change or upgrade applications to meet new industry trends can amount to costly and time-consuming integration projects all over. Thus, as the integration needs of an organization grow over time, adding more point-to-point integrations can become increasingly complex and challenging to maintain. This leads to scalability issues, limited visibility, and potential data silos.
As such, businesses with long-term integration strategies, seeking centralized control of their software connections and data, and with ambitions to build entire integration ecosystems, are turning to the iPaaS.
What is the Alumio iPaaS?
The Alumio iPaaS (integration Platform as a Service) is a cloud-native, low-code integration platform that helps connect multiple systems, SaaS, cloud apps, and data sources using APIs, without custom code. It provides a user-friendly web interface to create, monitor, and manage integrations, which both - developers and non-coding professionals (like business managers, data experts, and junior devs) can collaborate on.
Designed to make integrations simple for developers as a low-code solution, Alumio provides advanced integration features such as data mappers, data transformers, and workflow automation tools, enabling flexible customizations. It also enables synchronization and real-time data exchange between all integrated systems, along with a robust monitoring and logging system that enables real-time error detection.
The key differences in building integrations with the Alumio iPaaS
Providing a scalable and secure cloud space to centralize and unify multiple disparate integrations and data sources, the Alumio iPaaS is ideal for businesses looking to increase the number of integrations as they grow and to help organize scalable IT ecosystems. To encourage this, it also provides a rich library of connectors that help build faster and more flexible integrations with popular software. Additionally, as an API-driven solution, the Alumio iPaaS offers the freedom of integration interchangeability, wherein businesses can flexibly change integrated systems without loss of data integrity.
Point-to-point integrations vs. the Alumio iPaaS: Early verdict
In contrast to custom coding point-to-point integrations, the one crucial con of the Alumio iPaaS is that it may turn out to be an underutilized integration solution for businesses looking to connect no more than two applications. However, even in this scenario, the Alumio iPaaS offers the ability to integrate unlimited data flows between two integrated systems and to increase processing power in a scalable way.
Apart from this, when comparing the Alumio iPaaS vs point-to-point integrations, the verdict seems to be that the iPaaS offers a plethora of clear advantages to modern businesses. Yet, to explain why using the iPaaS is a better integration solution than building point-to-point integrations with custom code, let’s explore how these two differ in integration methods and the pros and cons that entail.
Why build integrations with the Alumio iPaaS vs custom code
Let’s take the common integration use case that involves a business wanting to connect its ERP system with an e-commerce platform to digitally grow and streamline operations. For instance, let’s assume the enterprise is looking to integrate the SAP ERP system with the BigCommerce e-commerce platform.
Traditionally, they would employ their IT teams or system integrators to connect these two systems with custom code in a point-to-point fashion. Apart from writing bespoke code, this involves developing a framework from scratch to build and govern the integration. This is costly, time-consuming, and requires senior developers or external integration experts to govern and troubleshoot the connections constantly.
The point-to-point integration journey with custom code
Here’s what the integration journey looks like when building point-to-point integrations with custom code:
As you can see from the “integration coding process” in the visual above, it takes a significant time to even get a 1:1 integration off the ground. It then takes even more time to develop and test the integration before taking it to market. Here are some business critical cons due to which the point-to-point integration method isn’t feasible for modern businesses:
X No ownership and control of integrations
X A one-off investment with risky project timelines
X Hidden running costs for hosting and future development efforts
X Lack of flexibility in reusing, changing, or expanding integrations
X Long lead times due to extensive development cycles
Most importantly, the biggest issue with custom code integrations is that integrating more software solutions or applications involves starting a whole new integration project. Furthermore, data sharing within custom code integrations is prone to human error, isn’t always real-time, and can result in more data silos the more you expand your integrations.
In contrast, the benefit of implementing an integration platform like Alumio is that it provides one scalable, cloud environment where businesses can freely add or interchange new software integrations, on top of existing ones, without fearing loss of data integrity. This is a distinguishing factor as the e-commerce market continues to rapidly evolve and the ever-increasing demand for omnichannel experiences calls for integrated IT ecosystems consisting of multiple integrated applications.
The multi-point integration journey with the integration platform
Designed to make integrations simple, the Alumio iPaaS is designed to help businesses skip the costs and hassles of building their own integration solution or framework. It provides a ready-to-use, cloud-native platform that can be accessed remotely from a user-friendly web interface.
Here’s what the integration journey with the Alumio integration platform looks like:
As an API-driven solution, Alumio helps businesses integrate two or multiple applications without custom code, by providing simple click-and-configure options to set up integrations instead. By helping to configure, test, and activate integrations quickly, the Alumio integration platform helps businesses achieve faster Time to Market (TTM) on their integration strategies. Here are some of the integration benefits it provides:
✔ Ownership and control of integrations.
✔ One-off investment with low-risk project timelines.
✔ Low maintenance cost. Reuse, change, and expand integrations on demand.
✔ The ability to train junior developers or project managers to govern integrations.
✔ Short lead times, as all integration components are pre-built and battle-tested.
By shortening, speeding up, and simplifying the integration journey in this manner, the Alumio iPaaS makes it possible for businesses to experiment with rapidly integrating multiple systems. In other words, in same the duration it takes to set up a point-to-point ERP to e-commerce integration, the Alumio iPaaS can integrate both the ERP and e-commerce platforms, while adding a PIM and CRM integration to the mix.
Point-to-point integrations vs the iPaaS: Post-integration benefits
Despite the comparison, it is essential to note that businesses choosing to build integrations with the iPaaS vs. custom code is still only one part of the integration journey. The other (more significant) part of the integration journey begins after the software connections are built.
After integrating systems, the daily data exchange between connected systems needs to be managed or modified. New product or order details need to be updated across connected systems. Workflows need to be scheduled. Data duplications and integration errors must be detected and resolved, while data flows must be transformed based on changing business requirements. While the Alumio iPaaS provides workflow automation features to streamline all these processes, custom code integrations might involve a more manual approach to these problems. At the same time, while the iPaaS provides automated monitoring and logging to detect integration errors in real-time, point-to-point integrations built with custom code will require senior developers or integration experts to manually monitor and troubleshoot integrations.
To add to this, as a cloud-native integration platform, Alumio leverages the power of clustered microservices technology, enabling exceptional performance, scalability, and data security. By enabling microservices-based isolation it provides greater security advantages, such as reducing attack surface, enhancing data resilience, enabling customizable security configurations, and ensuring regulatory compliance. It also provides reactivation procedures and data caching to ensure business continuity. Most importantly, Alumio enables compliance with essential data privacy regulations such as GDPR, SOC2, CCPA, HIPAA & FERPA.
In this and many other regards, having a central integration platform that helps automate all these integration processes, is what gives the Alumio iPaaS the edge versus point-to-point integrations.
Read more about the pros and cons of custom code integrations vs the iPaaS →
Point-to-point integrations vs the Alumio iPaaS: Final verdict
In the realm of business integrations, the Alumio iPaaS is designed to be a game-changer. It addresses the limitations of custom code integrations by offering faster Time to Market through rapid integration deployment, lower operational costs through automation, increased ROI through scalability, and centralized management. By choosing Alumio, you can optimize business processes and stay ahead in the competitive landscape, but most importantly, you can orchestrate an entire integrated ecosystem.
While point-to-point integrations offer customization and flexibility in how integrations are built, the Alumio iPaaS iPaaS offers customization and flexibility in terms of adding and interchanging application without loss of data integrity. The iPaaS also porvides limitless data transformation capabilities. Thus, while point-to-point integrations might still be the ideal choice for businesses looking to integrate two or three systems, the Alumio iPaaS emerges as the ideal choice for businesses looking for a scalable solution with which they can keep integrating new endpoints as they grow.
Read more about the cost optimization benefits of the Alumio iPaaS vs custom code →
Other blogs you might be interested in!
Get a free demo of the Alumio platform
